A Coral Springs homeowner lists their house for $425,000, accepts an offer, signs the contract, and then three weeks later gets a backup offer for $465,000. They call their agent and ask if they can cancel the first deal and take the higher one. The answer is no — and trying to do it anyway can land them in court.
Florida real estate contracts are legally binding the moment both parties sign. The standard FAR/BAR Residential Contract for Sale and Purchase doesn’t give sellers a “change of mind” clause. Once you execute that contract, you’re locked in unless the buyer fails to meet a contingency or both sides agree to cancel.
Need Legal Guidance? Talk to Eric Goldman Today.
Get answers to your real estate, landlord-tenant, or personal injury questions. Free consultations available for Florida residents.
What Happens if a Seller Tries to Walk Away
A seller who refuses to close without legal justification commits a breach of contract. The buyer doesn’t just lose their earnest money and walk away — they have multiple remedies under Florida law, and none of them are pleasant for the seller.
-
First, the buyer gets their deposit back. That’s automatic. But returning the deposit doesn’t erase the seller’s liability. The buyer can still sue for damages — the difference between the contract price and what they have to pay for a comparable property, plus costs like temporary housing, storage, and moving expenses they wouldn’t have incurred if the seller had honored the deal.
-
Second, the buyer can file for specific performance. That’s a court order forcing the seller to complete the sale. Florida courts routinely grant specific performance in real estate cases because every property is considered unique under the law. A judge can compel you to sell your house to the buyer at the agreed price, even if the market has moved and you’re leaving money on the table.
-
Third, if the contract includes an attorney’s fees provision — and the standard FAR/BAR contracts do — the seller pays both sides’ legal bills if the buyer wins. That can add tens of thousands of dollars to the cost of backing out.
The Only Legal Exits for a Seller
Sellers can terminate a contract without penalty in two situations: mutual agreement or buyer default.
-
Mutual cancellation requires both parties to sign a release. The buyer has to agree, and they usually want something in return — a portion of their earnest money for their time and expenses, or compensation for lost opportunity if they passed on other houses. You can’t unilaterally cancel and force the buyer to accept it.
-
Buyer default is more common. If the buyer misses a deadline — fails to deliver the earnest money deposit within three days, doesn’t secure financing by the deadline in Paragraph 8, or backs out without invoking a valid contingency — the seller can terminate and keep the deposit as liquidated damages. The FAR/BAR contract spells this out clearly. But the buyer has to actually breach. A seller can’t manufacture a default or refuse to cooperate with the buyer’s reasonable requests and then claim the buyer didn’t perform.
Inspection and appraisal issues don’t give the seller an out. If the inspection reveals problems and the buyer asks for repairs, the seller can refuse — but that just gives the buyer the option to terminate, not the seller. Same with appraisals. If the property appraises low and the buyer can’t close without the seller reducing the price, the buyer walks, not the seller.
What About Disclosure Problems
Florida imposes strict disclosure obligations on sellers, and violating them doesn’t give you a way out — it gives the buyer more ammunition. Under Johnson v. Davis, a 1985 Florida Supreme Court case that’s still controlling law, sellers must disclose any material defects they know about that aren’t readily observable. Material means something that affects the property’s value or desirability.
The standard FAR/BAR contract reinforces this in Paragraph 10. Sellers affirm that there are no unpermitted improvements, no material facts affecting value that haven’t been disclosed, and if the property is in a flood zone, that’s been disclosed too. Breach any of those and the buyer can sue for fraud, rescind the contract, recover damages, and in egregious cases, get punitive damages and attorney’s fees.
Say a seller knows the roof leaks but doesn’t mention it, hoping to close before the next rainstorm. The buyer discovers it post-closing. That’s not just a contract breach — that’s actionable fraud under Florida law. The buyer can sue for the cost of repairs, diminution in value, and if the seller’s concealment was willful, punitive damages. Cases like Jensen v. Bailey and Eiman make clear that sellers are liable even if they hired a contractor to fix the problem and thought it was resolved. You don’t get to hide defects and then claim ignorance.
Sellers sometimes think they can use a disclosure problem as a reason to cancel — “Oh, I just remembered there’s an issue, so let’s call this off.” That doesn’t work. The buyer can waive the issue and demand you close anyway, or sue for fraud. You can’t use your own breach as an escape hatch.
Escrow Disputes and Arbitration
When a seller refuses to close and the buyer demands their deposit back, the title company or escrow agent holding the earnest money won’t release it without either both parties’ written consent or a court order. The FAR/BAR contract gives the parties 30 days from the date of the dispute to attempt mediation. If that fails, the escrow agent can submit the matter to arbitration, file an interpleader action in court, or in some cases notify the Florida Real Estate Commission.
Arbitration under the contract follows AAA rules. The parties split the arbitrator’s fees. The arbitrator can’t rewrite the contract — they decide who’s entitled to the deposit and whether either side owes damages based on the evidence presented. If the contract includes an attorney’s fees clause, the prevailing party recovers their legal costs.
Most of these disputes settle before arbitration or trial because sellers realize they’re on the losing end. If the buyer has a signed contract and the seller just doesn’t want to sell anymore, there’s no real defense. Specific performance is almost certain, and the seller will pay both sides’ attorney’s fees on top of that.
How This Plays Out in Practice
Attorneys who handle real estate disputes in South Florida see a predictable pattern: seller lists property, market heats up, seller gets second thoughts or a better offer, seller’s agent tells them they’re stuck, seller calls a lawyer hoping for a loophole. There isn’t one.
The cleanest way out is to negotiate a mutual release with the buyer. Offer them $5,000 or $10,000 for their trouble, let them keep part of the earnest money, whatever it takes to get them to sign the cancellation agreement. That’s cheaper than litigation and faster than waiting for a judge to order you to close six months from now.
The messiest version is the seller who just refuses to show up at closing. The buyer sues, gets a judgment for specific performance, and the court orders the sale. The seller pays their own attorney, the buyer’s attorney, court costs, and still has to sell the house at the original contract price while the market may have softened. I’ve seen sellers turn a $40,000 difference in offers into a $70,000 loss after legal fees and a forced sale.
Cancellation rates hit 13.7% nationally in early 2026, but the vast majority of those are buyer-initiated — financing falls through, inspection reveals problems, buyer loses their job. Seller-initiated cancellations are rare because sellers know they’ll lose in court.
What Changed in 2026
The NAR settlement that took effect in mid-2024 changed how buyer’s agents get paid, but it didn’t touch the enforceability of purchase contracts. Buyer broker agreements are now required before showing property, and commission is no longer advertised on the MLS, but once a contract is signed, the same rules apply. A seller can’t back out because they don’t want to pay a buyer’s agent commission — that was negotiable before signing, not after.
Florida statutes governing real estate conveyances (Chapter 689) and the Florida Realtors’ standard contracts haven’t been amended to give sellers more exit rights. If anything, courts have become more willing to grant specific performance because real estate is treated as a unique asset under Florida law.
Protect Your Rights. Call Eric Goldman.
Whether you are buying a home, dealing with a landlord dispute, or recovering from an injury, Eric Goldman can help. Serving clients throughout Florida.
What to Do if You’re a Seller Having Second Thoughts
-
Call your attorney before you do anything. Do not ignore the buyer’s calls, refuse to sign documents, or miss the closing without talking to a lawyer first. Any of those can be used as evidence of bad faith and strengthen the buyer’s case for damages.
-
If you have a legitimate reason to terminate — the buyer missed a deadline, didn’t deliver the deposit, or failed to secure financing when required — your attorney can send a notice of default and termination under the contract terms. You need documentation. You need dates. You need to follow the exact procedure in the contract.
-
If you just don’t want to sell anymore, your attorney’s job is to negotiate the best possible settlement with the buyer. That means figuring out what it will cost to make them go away and whether that’s cheaper than the cost of losing in court. Sometimes it is. Sometimes the buyer is reasonable and agrees to a mutual release for a few thousand dollars. Sometimes they’re not, and you’re stuck.
One thing is certain — you can’t just decide the deal is off because you changed your mind. Florida contract law doesn’t work that way, and trying to force it will cost you more than the house is worth.
