Need Legal Guidance? Talk to Eric Goldman Today.
Get answers to your real estate, landlord-tenant, or personal injury questions. Free consultations available for Florida residents.
Introduction
Your neighbor just put a charcoal gray roof on his house three streets over. You submitted the exact same shingle color for approval. The architectural review committee denied yours with no explanation beyond “not in compliance with community standards.”
This happens constantly in Coral Springs. The city has some of the highest HOA density in Broward County, with communities like Charleston in the Pines charging median fees around $425 per month and maintaining strict design standards that go back decades. When those standards collide with what homeowners actually want to do with their property, the fights get expensive fast.
What gives an HOA the right to reject your roof color
Florida Statute §720.303 gives HOA boards broad authority to enforce the community’s recorded declaration of covenants. That declaration — filed in the Broward County public records when the neighborhood was built — typically includes language allowing the association to regulate “exterior modifications to preserve architectural harmony” or similar phrasing.
The HOA then creates architectural guidelines that detail exactly what that means: approved roof colors, fence height limits, paint palettes, driveway materials. These guidelines sit below the declaration in the document hierarchy but still carry legal weight as long as they don’t contradict the recorded covenants.
Here’s the part most Coral Springs homeowners miss: the architectural review committee doesn’t need to prove your dark roof will harm property values or create drainage issues. They only need to show that denying it is consistent with the written standards and that they’re applying those standards evenly across the community. That second part — even application — is where disputes actually have legs.
The documents that actually control your dispute
If you want to replace your roof and the HOA says no, pull three sets of documents immediately:
-
The declaration of covenants and all recorded amendments. Not the summary the board sends new owners — the actual recorded document from the Broward County Clerk’s office. This is the highest authority in the HOA document stack. If the declaration is silent on roof color or says only that roofs must be “harmonious,” a blanket ban on dark shingles in the architectural guidelines might not hold up.
-
The architectural guidelines themselves. Request the version that was in effect when you submitted your application. Boards sometimes update guidelines mid-year and then apply new rules retroactively, which creates procedural problems under Florida law.
-
The HOA’s official records showing other approvals in the past 24 months. Section 720.303(4) gives you the statutory right to inspect records including meeting minutes where the ARC discussed applications. If ten homes in your section got dark roofs approved between 2022 and 2024, and yours is the first denial, you’ve got a selective enforcement argument.
Selective enforcement is the most common winning defense
Florida courts have consistently held that HOAs cannot enforce restrictions arbitrarily. If the association allowed your neighbor to install the same roof color you’re proposing, they need a legitimate reason why yours is different. “We changed our mind about the standards” doesn’t cut it. “We didn’t notice the other violations” is not a defense — it’s evidence of poor governance.
A TikTok video that circulated in Coral Springs HOA groups last year showed a street with four dark roofs and one homeowner holding a denial letter for the exact same shingle. That’s textbook selective enforcement. The homeowner in that situation has a strong case in mediation or court, assuming they can document the other approvals through ARC records or photos with visible addresses.
Defense attorneys for HOAs know this. Most will push the board to settle during presuit mediation rather than try to explain to a judge why identical applications got different results.
The procedural traps that kill owner challenges before they start
You submitted your application in March. The ARC took 90 days to respond. Your governing documents say applications are deemed approved if the committee doesn’t respond within 60 days. You started work. Now the HOA is threatening fines.
This plays out differently depending on what your declaration actually says. Some Coral Springs HOA documents include automatic approval language. Most do not. If yours doesn’t explicitly say “failure to respond within X days constitutes approval,” you cannot rely on silence as permission. The safe move is always to get written approval before starting work, even if the deadline passes.
If the HOA does impose fines, they must follow Florida Statute §720.305 to the letter. That means at least 14 days’ written notice of the violation, an opportunity for a hearing before an independent fining committee, and committee approval before any fine is levied. The board cannot fine you directly. If they skip the hearing or use a committee that includes board members, the fine is unenforceable.
Fines for architectural violations max out at $100 per violation, up to $1,000 total, unless your governing documents specify a higher amount. But the HOA can also seek an injunction forcing you to remove or modify the work, and that’s where the real cost comes in. If a judge orders you to tear off a $15,000 roof and reinstall an approved color, you’re paying for the redo plus likely the HOA’s attorney fees if the governing documents include a prevailing-party fee-shifting clause.
City permits do not override HOA approval
Coral Springs requires building permits for most exterior structural work — roof replacements, additions, pool enclosures, fences over a certain height. Homeowners often get the city permit, assume they’re clear, and start work without HOA approval.
A city permit means you’re complying with Coral Springs building codes. It says nothing about whether you’re complying with your HOA’s recorded covenants. Those are two separate legal requirements. You can be 100% compliant with city code and still be in violation of your HOA restrictions.
The reverse is also true. HOA approval doesn’t mean you can skip the city permit. If your community’s architectural guidelines allow a 6-foot privacy fence but Coral Springs zoning limits fences in your area to 5 feet, the city requirement controls. The HOA cannot authorize you to violate municipal code.
Get both approvals before you start. Doing it in reverse order creates expensive problems.
Presuit mediation is mandatory for most covenant disputes
Florida Statute §720.311 requires presuit mediation before an owner or HOA can file a lawsuit over use of property or enforcement of covenants. That includes architectural disputes. If you sue the HOA without attempting mediation first, the court will stay or dismiss your case and send you to mediation.
The mediation requirement is not a waste of time. It forces both sides to lay out their positions in front of a neutral mediator, often an attorney experienced in HOA law. The mediator will tell the HOA if their denial is legally shaky and will tell you if your challenge has no realistic chance of success. Many Coral Springs architectural disputes settle at mediation because the cost of litigation — which can easily hit $20,000 to $40,000 per side — makes compromise the only rational option.
If mediation fails, the case moves to Broward County Circuit Court. The prevailing party typically recovers attorney fees if the governing documents include a fee-shifting provision, which most do. That fee risk cuts both ways. It gives owners leverage when the HOA’s position is weak, but it also makes owners think twice before filing marginal claims.
What actually happens in a lawsuit over an architectural denial
If mediation breaks down and you file suit seeking a declaratory judgment that your roof color complies with the covenants or that the HOA’s denial was arbitrary, the HOA will likely file a motion to dismiss or for summary judgment arguing that the denial was within their discretion under the governing documents.
Discovery is where these cases get decided. You subpoena ARC meeting minutes, emails between committee members, and records of every roof application in the past three years. If the records show inconsistent decisions, vague standards applied differently to different owners, or no written standards at all, the HOA’s defense collapses. If the records show clear written guidelines, consistent application, and a legitimate aesthetic reason for the denial, your case is much harder.
Judges give HOA boards significant deference. The legal standard is not whether the board made the best decision or the decision you would have made. It’s whether the decision was reasonable, consistent with the governing documents, and not arbitrary or discriminatory. That’s a high bar for owners to clear, which is why most successful challenges involve either selective enforcement or procedural violations under Chapter 720.
Cases that go to trial typically involve either very high dollar amounts — for example, a denied addition that cost $80,000 to design and permit — or principle-driven owners who refuse to settle. Trials in these disputes can take two to three years from filing to final judgment when you factor in discovery, motions, and court backlogs in Broward.
The most common Coral Springs architectural disputes involve roofs and paint
Roof color fights dominate Coral Springs HOA disputes. Older declarations were written in the 1980s and 1990s when light-colored barrel tile roofs were standard across South Florida. Homeowners replacing roofs today want modern architectural shingles in grays and dark browns. ARCs say no, citing “community character” or outdated color charts.
Paint disputes run a close second. An owner picks a fashionable exterior color from a current Sherwin-Williams palette. The ARC pulls out a color book from 2003 and says the chosen color isn’t on the approved list. The owner argues the old list is unenforceable because it’s not in the recorded declaration. The ARC argues the declaration gives them authority to maintain a color list, and owners agreed to follow it when they bought in.
Fence and screen enclosure modifications also generate steady conflict. A homeowner wants to replace a deteriorating wood fence with maintenance-free PVC. The architectural guidelines specify wood only. The owner argues PVC is visually identical and superior in durability. The ARC denies it because the guidelines don’t list PVC as an approved material.
These disputes feel petty but the legal principles are identical to higher-stakes cases. The question is always whether the HOA is acting within its authority under the governing documents and applying its standards consistently.
Protect Your Rights. Call Eric Goldman.
Whether you are buying a home, dealing with a landlord dispute, or recovering from an injury, Eric Goldman can help. Serving clients throughout Florida.
When to push back and when to compromise
If your architectural application gets denied and you’re confident the denial is inconsistent with how the HOA has treated similar requests, request the records and push back. Document everything. Take photos of comparable homes. Get the written guidelines. Ask the ARC to explain in writing which specific provision of the declaration or guidelines your application violates.
If the HOA’s position is legally sound — your proposed modification clearly violates a recorded restriction that’s been consistently enforced — your options narrow. You can either modify the application to comply or challenge the restriction itself as unreasonable, which is a much harder case to win.
Compromise often makes sense when the dispute is over details rather than the project itself. The HOA won’t approve your charcoal roof but will approve a medium gray. You wanted a 6-foot fence but they’ll approve 5.5 feet. Fighting over half a foot of fence height or one shade of gray is rarely worth the cost of mediation and litigation.
But when the HOA is blocking a legitimate improvement based on outdated or selectively enforced standards, and you’ve got the records to prove inconsistent treatment, that’s when you lawyer up and push it through the formal dispute process. Most Coral Springs HOAs will settle reasonable claims during mediation rather than risk a fee-shifting judgment at trial.
Check your declaration and amendments before you submit any application. Compare your request to what the HOA has recently approved for other owners. Keep copies of everything you submit and every response you receive. If you’re denied, ask for the specific rule that supports the denial and proof that the rule is being applied consistently across the community. Those steps won’t prevent every dispute, but they’ll put you in a much stronger position if the dispute turns into a legal fight.
