A homeowner in Coral Springs files a claim after hurricane damage tears shingles off the roof and floods the master bedroom. The insurance company sends an adjuster who low-balls the estimate at $8,200. A contractor quotes $34,000 for proper repairs using like kind and quality materials. The insurer offers a final settlement of $11,500 — take it or leave it. This is when most people call a property damage attorney.
Florida changed the rules on property insurance lawsuits in 2023, and the changes hit policyholders hard. What used to be a five-year window to sue your insurer is now two years from the date of loss. Miss that deadline and your claim dies, even if the damage is real and the denial was bogus. Nearly 50% of residential claims filed after major hurricanes in 2024 closed without a single dollar paid out, according to the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation. That’s not an accident — it’s the result of insurers playing hardball in a system that now favors them more than it used to.
Need Legal Guidance? Talk to Eric Goldman Today.
Get answers to your real estate, landlord-tenant, or personal injury questions. Free consultations available for Florida residents.
What Property Damage Attorneys Handle in Florida
Property damage cases fall into two main buckets: insurance disputes and third-party negligence claims. Insurance cases dominate the practice. Homeowners fight with carriers over storm damage, fire damage, water intrusion, and roof failures. These disputes almost always involve one of three problems — the insurer denies the claim outright, pays a fraction of what repairs actually cost, or slow-walks the process hoping the homeowner gives up.
Third-party negligence cases are different. A neighbor’s tree falls on your fence. A contractor’s crew damages your driveway. A delivery truck backs into your garage. You’re not dealing with your own insurer — you’re going after whoever caused the damage. Florida Statutes §95.11(3) gives you four years from the date of damage to file a lawsuit for general property damage caused by negligence. That’s a longer runway than the two-year window for suing your own insurance company, but the four-year clock still runs faster than most people realize.
Auto property damage is its own animal. Florida requires drivers to carry a minimum of $10,000 in property damage liability coverage under Florida Statutes §627.7275. That coverage pays for damage you cause to someone else’s car or property — not your own. If someone rear-ends you at a red light and totals your car, you’re making a claim against their property damage liability policy. If they don’t have insurance or their policy limits are too low, you’re stuck unless you bought underinsured motorist coverage. You have four years to sue the at-fault driver under the same statute that governs other negligence claims.
How Florida’s 2023 Insurance Reforms Changed the Game
Before 2023, policyholders could sue their homeowners’ insurance company up to five years after a loss under the general statute of limitations for written contracts. Senate Bill 2A cut that window to two years from the date of loss for property insurance claims filed after the reforms took effect. The change was sold as a way to reduce litigation and stabilize the insurance market. What it actually did was give insurers more leverage to delay and lowball claims, knowing the clock runs out faster.
The reforms also gutted the one-way attorney fee provision under Florida Statutes §627.428. That statute used to let policyholders recover their legal fees if they won a lawsuit against their insurer, even if the insurer didn’t have to pay the policyholder’s fees if the insurer won. It leveled the playing field. Now, for most residential and commercial property claims filed after the reforms, each side pays their own attorney fees unless there’s a settlement agreement, a contract provision, or a successful bad faith claim. That makes it harder for homeowners to find lawyers willing to take smaller cases on contingency.
Bad faith claims — lawsuits against insurers for unreasonable claim handling — got harder too. Florida Statutes §624.155 still allows bad faith claims, but the 2023 amendments now require you to win a breach of contract lawsuit first. You can’t go straight to bad faith anymore. You have to prove the insurer violated the policy, get a judgment, and then pursue extra-contractual damages for bad faith. That adds time, cost, and risk.
The appraisal process survived the reforms. If you and your insurer disagree about how much a covered loss is worth — not whether it’s covered, just how much it’s worth — either side can invoke appraisal under Florida Statutes §627.7074. Each party picks an appraiser. Those two appraisers pick an umpire. Any two of the three must agree on the loss amount, and that decision is binding. Appraisal is faster and cheaper than litigation, but it only works for valuation disputes. If the insurer denies coverage altogether, appraisal won’t help.
Deadlines That Kill Claims Before They Start
Florida Statutes §627.70132 requires homeowners to file new or reopened residential property insurance claims within one year from the date of loss. Not from the date you discovered the damage — from the date it happened. A roof leak that started during a storm in June 2024 but didn’t cause visible interior damage until September 2024 still has a one-year deadline running from June 2024. Miss that deadline and the insurer can deny your claim on timeliness alone, regardless of how legitimate the damage is.
Once you file a claim, the insurer has strict deadlines under Florida Statutes §627.70131. They must acknowledge your claim within 14 days. They must start an investigation within 14 days. They must pay, deny, or request additional information within 90 days. If they blow those deadlines, interest starts accruing on any amount they eventually owe, and the delay can support a bad faith claim if the case goes that far. But enforcement is spotty. Insurers routinely miss the 90-day deadline and face no real consequences unless the policyholder lawyers up and pushes back.
The two-year statute of limitations for filing a lawsuit against your insurer runs from the date of loss, not from the date they deny your claim. A homeowner whose roof was damaged in a July 2024 storm has until July 2026 to file a lawsuit if the insurer denies or underpays the claim. That sounds like plenty of time, but it’s not. You need to document the damage, get repair estimates, fight with the adjuster, exhaust the appraisal process if applicable, send a Civil Remedy Notice if you’re considering bad faith, wait 60 days for the insurer to respond, and then file suit. Two years evaporates fast.
What Insurers Do to Avoid Paying Claims
The most common tactic is depreciation games. Florida Statutes §627.7011 requires residential property policies to cover the full cost of repairs using like kind and quality materials. Insurers are supposed to pay replacement cost, not actual cash value minus depreciation. But adjusters routinely issue estimates based on depreciated values, hoping homeowners don’t know the difference. A roof replacement might cost $40,000, but the adjuster offers $22,000 after depreciation. The policy usually allows the insurer to withhold depreciation until repairs are complete, but the initial estimate should still reflect the full replacement cost.
Another move is the scope dispute. The adjuster inspects the damage and writes an estimate that covers half of what actually needs repair. They’ll approve replacing 12 squares of shingles when the contractor says the whole roof needs to go. Or they’ll pay to dry out water damage but deny coverage for the mold that grew because they took three weeks to approve the drying. Engineers and contractors become critical witnesses in these cases because the insurer’s estimate almost never matches reality.
Causation denials are harder to fight. The insurer admits the damage exists but claims it wasn’t caused by a covered peril. Your roof is leaking, but they say it’s due to wear and tear or poor maintenance, not the hurricane. Florida policies exclude damage from wear and tear, but they cover sudden and accidental losses. If a storm exposes a pre-existing weakness and causes new damage, the new damage is covered. The insurer will argue otherwise. You’ll need an engineer’s report to win.
When to Hire a Property Damage Attorney
Hire one the moment the insurer denies your claim or offers a settlement that doesn’t come close to covering repairs. Do not wait. The deadlines are unforgiving, and insurers count on you not knowing the rules. Most property damage attorneys work on contingency — they take a percentage of whatever they recover, and if they don’t win, you don’t pay. Typical contingency fees run 25% to 40% depending on how far the case goes.
If the insurer hasn’t denied your claim yet but you’re getting the runaround — missed deadlines, unanswered calls, lowball estimates — bring in an attorney before the situation turns into a formal denial. Once the denial letter arrives, your options narrow. You’re either heading to appraisal, filing a lawsuit, or walking away. An attorney can sometimes get the insurer to reverse course before it gets that far, especially if the file shows obvious violations of the claim-handling statutes.
For third-party negligence cases — someone else damaged your property and you’re going after them, not your insurer — the math is different. If the damage is minor and the at-fault party has insurance, you might be able to settle directly with their carrier. But if they’re uninsured, underinsured, or their carrier is denying liability, you need a lawyer. You have four years to sue under Florida Statutes §95.11(3), but waiting years to act kills your case. Witnesses disappear. Evidence gets lost. Memories fade.
What Happens If You’re Partly at Fault
Florida’s modified comparative negligence rule under Florida Statutes §768.81 applies to property damage claims the same way it applies to personal injury. If you’re 51% or more responsible for the damage, you recover nothing. If you’re 30% at fault, your recovery gets reduced by 30%. This comes up more than you’d think in property damage cases.
Say a tenant’s washing machine hose bursts and floods the unit. The landlord sues the tenant for property damage. The tenant argues the landlord never replaced the 15-year-old hoses despite repeated requests. A jury could find both parties partially at fault — the tenant for not turning off the water supply when they noticed a slow leak, the landlord for failing to maintain the appliances. If the jury assigns 60% fault to the tenant and 40% to the landlord, the landlord recovers 40% of the proven damages.
Defense attorneys use comparative negligence to pressure plaintiffs into settling for less. They’ll argue you failed to mitigate damages, didn’t maintain your property, or ignored obvious warning signs. Document everything from the start — photos, videos, repair records, correspondence. If you can show you did everything a reasonable property owner would do, comparative negligence becomes a harder sell.
Protect Your Rights. Call Eric Goldman.
Whether you are buying a home, dealing with a landlord dispute, or recovering from an injury, Eric Goldman can help. Serving clients throughout Florida.
The Civil Remedy Notice Requirement for Bad Faith Claims
Before you can sue an insurer for bad faith under Florida Statutes §624.155, you must send a Civil Remedy Notice to the Florida Department of Financial Services. The notice must describe the insurer’s alleged violations — unreasonable denial, delay, underpayment, failure to investigate. The insurer then has 60 days to cure the violation. If they pay what they owe or fix the problem within 60 days, you can’t pursue bad faith.
Most insurers ignore the Civil Remedy Notice or respond with a token gesture that doesn’t fix the underlying problem. Once the 60 days expire, you can file a bad faith lawsuit, but only after you’ve already won a breach of contract case proving the insurer violated the policy. The 2023 reforms made this a two-step process. First, sue for breach of contract and get a judgment. Then, sue for bad faith to recover damages beyond the policy limits — things like emotional distress, financial harm from the delay, and attorney fees.
Bad faith cases are expensive and time-consuming. They’re worth pursuing when the insurer’s conduct was egregious and the damages are substantial. A $15,000 underpayment probably isn’t worth a bad faith lawsuit. A $200,000 denial on a total loss where the insurer fabricated reasons to avoid coverage — that’s a different story.
If your claim was denied, your settlement offer doesn’t cover half of what repairs cost, or your insurer has been stalling for months, call the Law Offices of Eric J. Goldman. We handle property damage cases throughout Broward, Palm Beach, and Miami-Dade. The consultation is free, and we work on contingency. The deadlines are shorter than they used to be, and the insurance companies know it.
