A $32.3 million special assessment. That’s what five Brickell Key condo associations sued Swire over in 2024, arguing the developer improperly shifted seawall and baywalk repair costs onto owners. The lawsuit challenged whether the association even had the authority to assess owners for work on property the owners didn’t own. Whether the plaintiffs win or lose, every unit owner in those buildings got hit with a bill they didn’t see coming when they closed.
This is the new reality in Brickell. Special assessments used to be rare events triggered by hurricanes or sudden structural failures. Now they’re baked into the cost of owning an older high-rise condo in South Florida. Florida’s post-Surfside reforms changed the game. Milestone inspections and structural integrity reserve studies have forced associations to confront decades of deferred maintenance. Buildings that looked pristine on the outside are discovering concrete spalling, corroded rebar, and waterproofing failures that cost millions to fix. When reserves are empty, the only option is a special assessment.
Buyers touring a Brickell condo with water views and high-end finishes rarely ask about the reserve study or the last milestone inspection. They should. A low monthly maintenance fee can signal that the association has been underfunding reserves for years and is about to shift those costs onto owners all at once.
Need Legal Guidance? Talk to Eric Goldman Today.
Get answers to your real estate, landlord-tenant, or personal injury questions. Free consultations available for Florida residents.
What a special assessment actually is
A special assessment is an extra charge the association levies when regular monthly dues and reserve funds aren’t enough to cover a major expense. The expense could be structural repairs, seawall work, roof replacement, plumbing system upgrades, or even insurance shortfalls. The association votes to approve the assessment, then divides the total cost among unit owners based on their ownership share.
Special assessments are not loans. You don’t pay them back over time unless the association decides to let you. Some associations bill the full amount immediately. Others spread payments over 12 or 24 months. A few will finance the work and let owners pay in installments, but that’s a courtesy, not a right.
Florida law gives associations broad authority to levy special assessments for necessary repairs and maintenance. The declaration and bylaws set the approval threshold, usually a majority or supermajority of voting interests. Owners can’t refuse to pay just because they voted against the assessment. Once it’s approved, it becomes a lien on your unit. If you don’t pay, the association can foreclose.
The Brickell Key lawsuit shows how assessment disputes can get complicated fast. The plaintiffs argued the seawall and baywalk sat on property the owners didn’t own and weren’t responsible for maintaining. They also claimed the association never properly approved the assessment under the governing documents. Even if they’re right, they still had to pay the assessment upfront while the case worked its way through court. That’s how Florida law works: you pay first, litigate later.
Why Brickell condos face higher assessment risk
Brickell has some of the oldest luxury high-rise condos in South Florida. Many were built in the 1980s and 1990s, which means they’re now hitting the 30- and 40-year mark where major building systems start to fail. Concrete deteriorates. Waterproofing membranes crack. Seawalls corrode. Elevator modernization becomes mandatory. These aren’t cosmetic issues. They’re structural, and they’re expensive.
Coastal exposure makes it worse. Salt air accelerates concrete spalling and rebar corrosion. Brickell condos sit right on Biscayne Bay, which means they take the full brunt of humidity, salt spray, and storm surge. The seawall work that triggered the $32.3 million Brickell Key assessment is a perfect example. Seawalls don’t last forever, and when they fail, the repair bill is enormous.
Florida’s milestone inspection law added a new layer of exposure. Any condo building three stories or higher and at least 30 years old must complete a milestone inspection. If the building is within three miles of the coast, the deadline is 25 years. The inspection evaluates structural integrity, including load-bearing elements, waterproofing, and exterior walls. If the inspector finds substantial deterioration, the association must complete a phase-two inspection and make all necessary repairs.
Structural integrity reserve studies make the problem even more visible. Florida law now requires associations to conduct a SIRS that identifies major building components, estimates their remaining useful life, and calculates how much money the association needs to set aside each year. If the reserve study shows the association has been underfunding reserves for decades, owners can’t ignore it anymore. The board either starts funding reserves at the required level, which means raising monthly dues, or it levies a special assessment to catch up.
Most Brickell buyers don’t ask to see the milestone inspection report or the SIRS before closing. They should. Those two documents tell you whether the building is financially stable or about to hit owners with a six-figure assessment.
What buyers should review before closing
The estoppel letter is not enough. The estoppel tells you whether the seller owes past-due assessments and whether there are any current special assessments on the books. It doesn’t tell you whether the association is about to approve a new one.
You need to review the association’s budget, financial statements, and reserve schedule. Look at how much money the association has in reserves and compare it to the SIRS funding requirements. If reserves are significantly underfunded, that’s a red flag. It means the association is either about to raise monthly dues or levy a special assessment to close the gap.
Board and committee minutes are even more revealing. Minutes often disclose repair bids, engineering reports, and discussions of upcoming assessments months before they show up in the budget. If the board is getting quotes for concrete restoration or seawall work, you can assume an assessment is coming. If the minutes mention a reserve loan or deferred maintenance, that’s another warning sign.
The milestone inspection summary should be part of the closing package. If the building completed a milestone inspection and the inspector found substantial deterioration, you need to know what repairs are required and whether they’ve been completed. If the building hasn’t completed the milestone inspection yet, you need to know when it’s due. Associations that miss the deadline face fines from the state, and those fines get passed on to owners.
The SIRS is just as important. If the association hasn’t completed a SIRS yet, ask why. The law requires it. If the association completed the SIRS but isn’t funding reserves at the recommended level, ask what the plan is. Some associations vote to waive or reduce reserve funding, but that just shifts the cost to a future special assessment.
You should also review the declaration, articles of incorporation, bylaws, and rules. These documents set the approval threshold for special assessments and define what common property the association is responsible for maintaining. The Brickell Key lawsuit turned partly on whether the seawall and baywalk were common elements the association could assess owners for. If the governing documents are ambiguous about property boundaries or maintenance responsibilities, that ambiguity can turn into expensive litigation.
Red flags that signal an assessment is coming
- Low monthly maintenance fees in a 30-year-old building are not a selling point. They’re a warning sign. Associations keep maintenance fees low by underfunding reserves and deferring repairs. Eventually the building needs work, and when reserves are empty, the only option is a special assessment.
- Missing or incomplete inspection reports. If the building is old enough to require a milestone inspection but the seller can’t produce the report, that’s a problem. Either the association missed the deadline, which means fines are piling up, or the inspection found problems the association doesn’t want buyers to see.
- Recent or planned litigation. If the association is suing the developer, the contractor, or another party, that litigation is expensive. Even if the association wins, legal fees often run into six figures. Those fees get paid through special assessments or reserve loans, which means owners foot the bill either way.
- Deferred maintenance appearing in minutes and financial statements. If the board has been postponing roof replacement, elevator modernization, or plumbing upgrades for years, those projects are still going to happen. The longer the association waits, the more expensive the repairs become.
- Lender concerns. If your mortgage lender reviews the condo questionnaire and flags reserve funding or pending assessments as a problem, take that seriously. Lenders see hundreds of condo deals. When they refuse to finance a unit because of reserve issues or assessment risk, they’re telling you the building is financially unstable.
How special assessments affect financing and resale
Special assessments don’t just hit your bank account once. They affect your ability to sell the unit later. Buyers and lenders view buildings with frequent assessments as higher risk. If your building levies a major assessment every few years, future buyers will either demand a price discount or walk away.
Lenders are especially cautious about buildings with low reserves or pending assessments. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have specific reserve requirements for condo financing. If the association’s reserve fund falls below a certain percentage of the annual budget, conventional financing becomes difficult or impossible. FHA has even stricter rules. If the building isn’t FHA-approved, buyers who need FHA loans can’t purchase units there.
Some lenders will finance a unit even if there’s a pending assessment, but they’ll require proof that the seller is paying the assessment in full at closing. If the seller refuses, you’re stuck either paying it yourself or losing the deal. That’s why you need to know about pending assessments before you sign the contract, not three days before closing.
Special assessments also affect your monthly cash flow. For example, say you’re buying a Brickell condo with $800 monthly maintenance fees. The association levies a $50,000 special assessment payable over 24 months. That’s an extra $2,083 per month on top of your mortgage, taxes, insurance, and regular maintenance fees. If you’re renting the unit out, that assessment can wipe out your rental income for two years.
What to ask before you close
- Has the building completed its milestone inspection? If yes, did the inspector require a phase-two review or report substantial deterioration? If no, when is it due?
- Has the association completed a SIRS? If yes, does the current budget fund reserves at the level required by the study? If no, when will it be completed?
- Are there any current, pending, or recently approved special assessments? Don’t rely on the estoppel alone. Ask the board directly and review the minutes.
- Are any major repairs being financed by reserve loans or deferred because of cash-flow problems? If the association borrowed from reserves to cover operating expenses, that’s a sign of financial trouble.
- Are there unresolved issues involving seawalls, concrete restoration, waterproofing, roofs, elevators, plumbing, or electrical systems? If the board is getting quotes for major work, an assessment is likely coming.
- Are there any lawsuits, engineering reports, or local recertification issues that could lead to additional assessments? Litigation is expensive even when the association wins.
- Is your lender willing to finance the unit given the association’s reserve funding and assessment exposure? If the lender raises concerns, don’t assume you can refinance later. The next lender will see the same problems.
Protect Your Rights. Call Eric Goldman.
Whether you are buying a home, dealing with a landlord dispute, or recovering from an injury, Eric Goldman can help. Serving clients throughout Florida.
Protecting yourself before you sign
You have leverage before you close. Once you own the unit, you’re subject to whatever assessments the board approves. Use the inspection period to review every document the association has. If the seller or listing agent says the association is financially stable, ask for proof. Verbal assurances mean nothing.
If you discover a pending assessment or low reserves during the inspection period, you have options:
- Negotiate a price reduction.
- Ask the seller to pay the assessment at closing.
- Walk away and get your deposit back.
What you can’t do is ignore the problem and hope it goes away.
Some buyers assume they can challenge an assessment after they close if it seems unfair or excessive. That’s not how Florida law works. Courts give condo associations wide discretion to levy assessments for necessary repairs. Unless the board acted fraudulently or violated the governing documents, the assessment stands. Your only real recourse is to vote out the board at the next election, which doesn’t help you avoid paying the assessment that’s already been approved.
A Brickell condo can still be a smart purchase even if the building has assessment risk. But you need to price that risk into your offer. If the reserve study shows the building needs $10 million in repairs over the next five years and reserves are empty, assume you’ll be paying your share of that $10 million through special assessments. Adjust your offer accordingly, or find a building with better financials.
