Need Legal Guidance? Talk to Eric Goldman Today.
Get answers to your real estate, landlord-tenant, or personal injury questions. Free consultations available for Florida residents.
Introduction
You’re two days from closing on a house in Plantation and the title company calls. There’s a $22,000 mechanic’s lien from 2019 that the seller never mentioned. Your lender won’t fund the loan. The moving truck is already booked. This is the nightmare scenario that makes title searches worth every penny.
A title search examines public records to confirm who owns the property and whether any liens, judgments, or other claims cloud the title. When problems surface — and they do more often than most buyers expect — you get a title commitment listing every defect that needs resolution before closing. Florida law doesn’t let you transfer marketable title when these issues exist. The deal stops until someone fixes them or you negotiate around them.
What Shows Up in a Florida Title Search
Title examiners comb through deed records, court filings, tax rolls, and mortgage databases looking for anything that affects ownership. They’re guided by Florida’s Uniform Title Standards, which standardize how to treat common defects so transactions don’t grind to a halt over minor technicalities.
Liens are the most common problem. Unpaid mortgages, property tax liens, HOA assessments, contractor mechanic’s liens, and judgment liens all attach to the property itself. Here’s the part that surprises people: Florida’s homestead protection under Article X, Section 4 of the state constitution shields your primary residence from most judgment liens. If someone sues you and wins a $50,000 judgment, they generally can’t force the sale of your homestead to collect. But that protection has holes. Property taxes, special assessments, and HOA liens punch straight through homestead status. So does any lien you voluntarily agreed to, like a mortgage or home equity line.
Recording errors create another category of headaches. A misspelled name on a deed, an unrecorded mortgage satisfaction, or a forged signature can all invalidate what looks like a clean chain of title. Chapter 695 of the Florida Statutes requires proper recording of conveyances and liens for them to be valid against third parties, but clerical mistakes happen constantly in county recorder offices across South Florida.
Boundary disputes and encroachments show up on surveys, not title searches, but they often surface during the same due diligence period. Say the neighbor’s fence cuts three feet into what’s supposed to be your backyard, or an easement gives the power company access to half your side yard. These aren’t always deal-killers, but they affect value and use.
Fraudulent conveyances are rarer but devastating when they occur. Someone forges a deed and “sells” property they don’t own. Florida Statute Section 65.091 created a streamlined quiet title procedure specifically for fraud cases, allowing victims to restore their title through summary proceedings rather than full trials.
How the Process Works After Problems Surface
The title company issues a preliminary title commitment before closing. Schedule B of that commitment lists every exception to coverage — the known defects they won’t insure against unless resolved. This is your roadmap of problems.
Most purchase contracts in Florida use the Florida Realtors/Florida Bar (FAR/BAR) standard forms, which give the seller a reasonable time to cure title defects. The seller typically handles payoffs for their own mortgages and liens. If there’s a $15,000 judgment lien from a credit card lawsuit, the seller either pays it at closing from sale proceeds or negotiates with the creditor for a payoff amount.
But not every problem has a clean solution. Say the title search reveals an unrecorded easement that gives a neighboring property owner the right to cross your land to access the street. The seller might not have known about it. You can’t make it disappear. Your options narrow to three:
- Accept the easement and close anyway.
- Negotiate a price reduction to compensate for the reduced value.
- Terminate the contract if the deadline to cure passes without resolution.
Title insurance becomes critical here. An owner’s title policy protects against defects that existed before you bought but weren’t discovered during the search. Florida Statute Section 627.7841 requires title insurers to cover the gap between the commitment date and the actual recording date if they’re handling the closing funds. If a lien gets filed during that window, the policy covers it.
The policy doesn’t just cut you a check if a problem surfaces later. The insurer has three options:
- Pay to cure the defect (for example, filing a quiet title action to remove a cloud).
- Defend your title in court if someone challenges it.
- Indemnify you up to the policy limit if you lose ownership.
Most claims get resolved through the first two options.
When You Need a Quiet Title Action
Some defects can’t be fixed with a phone call and a wire transfer. A quiet title action under Chapter 65 of the Florida Statutes is a lawsuit filed in the circuit court where the property sits. You’re asking a judge to declare that certain claims against your property are invalid and to “quiet” the title by removing those clouds.
The process starts with a comprehensive title search identifying every person or entity with a potential claim. You file a complaint naming all known parties and record a lis pendens — notice of pending litigation — which prevents anyone from transferring or encumbering the property while the case is active. Chapter 695 recording requirements apply to the lis pendens just like any other document affecting title.
Service of process gets tricky. Known parties get personally served. Unknown heirs or claimants whose identities you can’t determine after reasonable investigation get served through publication in a local newspaper. Most quiet title actions end in default judgment because the adverse claimants either don’t exist, can’t be located, or don’t bother responding. Contested cases go to trial.
Fraud cases under Section 65.091 get priority scheduling. If someone forged your mother’s signature on a deed transferring her Coral Springs condo to a scammer, you can use this streamlined procedure to restore title relatively quickly. The statute recognizes that fraud victims shouldn’t wait years for relief.
Quiet title actions aren’t cheap. Between filing fees, service costs, publication expenses, and attorney fees, you’re looking at $5,000 to $15,000 for an uncontested case. Contested cases with real disputes over ownership can easily hit $30,000 or more. This is exactly why title insurance exists — the policy pays these costs if a covered defect surfaces.
What Sellers Must Disclose
Florida law requires sellers to disclose material defects that aren’t readily observable and that affect the property’s value. The landmark case Johnson v. Davis (1985) established that sellers have an affirmative duty to disclose known problems even if the buyer doesn’t ask. Section 689.302 specifically requires disclosure if the property is in a flood zone.
But here’s what catches people: the seller’s disclosure obligation covers physical defects and certain legal issues, but it doesn’t always extend to title problems. If the seller genuinely doesn’t know about a 1987 judgment lien buried in the public records, they can’t disclose it. That’s why buyers order their own title search rather than relying on seller representations.
Standard contracts require sellers to affirm that they’ve pulled all required permits for improvements and that no facts materially affect the property’s value. A seller who added a room without permits or knows the HOA is about to levy a $20,000 special assessment for roof replacement has to disclose those facts. Failure to disclose can support a fraud claim after closing, but you’d rather know before you buy.
The Marketable Title Standard
Florida requires sellers to deliver “marketable title” at closing. That’s title that’s insurable by a reputable title company at standard rates and free from reasonable doubt or litigation risk. The Uniform Title Standards published by the Florida Bar provide guidance on what defects make title unmarketable.
A $500 mechanic’s lien from 2015 that was never properly perfected might not make title unmarketable if the claim is clearly time-barred under Florida’s lien statutes. But a properly recorded $50,000 judgment lien absolutely does. The standards help attorneys and title companies make consistent decisions about which defects must be cured and which can be insured over.
Most buyers don’t realize that “marketable title” and “insurable title” aren’t quite the same thing. Title companies will sometimes issue policies with exceptions for defects they consider low-risk, even though those defects technically cloud the title. You might get insurance, but you’re accepting the risk that the exception could cause problems later. An attorney reviewing your title commitment can flag these situations before you close.
When Title Insurance Pays Claims
Say you buy a house in Davie and two years later someone files a lawsuit claiming they have a valid easement across your property that didn’t show up in the title search. You notify your title insurance company immediately. The insurer assigns a claims examiner who reviews the policy, the title search, and the adverse claim.
If the claim falls within your coverage, the insurer hires an attorney to defend you. They might file a quiet title action to eliminate the claimed easement, or they might negotiate a settlement with the claimant. You don’t pay legal fees out of pocket — the policy covers defense costs in addition to the policy limit.
If the claim is valid and you lose, the insurer either pays to cure the problem or indemnifies you for your loss up to the policy amount. Most residential policies are issued for the purchase price of the property, which might not fully protect you if the property has appreciated significantly. That’s why some buyers increase their coverage or buy inflation riders.
Florida’s statute of limitations for title insurance claims is five years from discovery of the defect under Section 95.11(2)(e). But claims based on fraud have different limitations periods, and coverage disputes with insurers can turn on policy language and timing. The critical move is notifying your insurer promptly when any title issue surfaces. Delayed notice can give the company grounds to deny coverage.
Protect Your Rights. Call Eric Goldman.
Whether you are buying a home, dealing with a landlord dispute, or recovering from an injury, Eric Goldman can help. Serving clients throughout Florida.
What Actually Happens at the Closing Table
Most title problems get resolved before closing, not after. The seller pays off liens from sale proceeds. The title company obtains updated tax certificates and lien searches within 24 hours of closing to catch any last-minute filings. Section 627.7841 protects you during that gap period if you’re using the title company’s closing services.
But sometimes deals close with known exceptions. Say there’s a utility easement running along the back property line. It’s valid, it’s recorded, and it’s not going away. The title policy lists it as a Schedule B exception — meaning you’re buying the property subject to that easement and the policy won’t cover any loss related to it. As long as you understand what you’re accepting, that’s a legitimate way to close.
Other times, the seller can’t cure a defect by the contract deadline and you have to decide whether to extend, renegotiate, or walk away. Standard FAR/BAR contracts give you the right to terminate if the seller can’t deliver marketable title. You get your deposit back and you move on. It’s frustrating, but it beats closing on a property with a $40,000 unresolved lien and fighting about it in court for the next two years.
The title company doesn’t represent you. They represent the transaction. An attorney reviewing your title commitment before closing works for you and only you. That attorney can spot problems the title company is willing to insure over but that could cost you serious money down the road. In Florida, you’re not required to have an attorney at closing. But the people who skip legal review and later discover title problems they didn’t understand almost universally wish they’d spent the $500 to $1,000 for representation up front.
If your title search reveals problems, don’t let anyone pressure you to close anyway because “it’s probably fine” or “title insurance will cover it.” Get specific answers about what the defect means, how it affects your ownership rights, and what your real options are. The time to protect yourself is before you sign, not after.
